| Hour 1 |
| Dr. D - Utensils, The |
| Doctor of Dementia - Dr. Demento w/ Barnes & Barnes |
| She's Kara Zor-El - great Luke Ski, The |
| Black Panther Strikes! - Scales & Kingston |
| What Do I Know? - Ed Sheeran & Kurupt FM |
| Stick It Out - Right Said Fred |
| Freaky Friday - Lil Dicky feat. Chris Brown |
| Oops!... I Did It Again - Shek Baker (as Louis Armstrong) |
| Wonderwall - Mike Flowers Pops, The |
| You Can't Sit Down in a Stormtrooper Costume - Carla Ulbrich |
| You Can't Roller Skate in a Buffalo Herd - Roger Miller |
| T-Rex Song (Director's Cut), The - great Luke Ski feat. Nostalgia Critic, The |
| Masochism Tango (orchestral version), The - Tom Lehrer |
| Poisoning Pigeons in the Park (orchestral version) - Tom Lehrer |
| Snow Fairy - Funkist |
| Hour 2 |
| Lil' Red Riding Hood - Sam the Sham & The Pharaohs |
| Little Blue Riding Hood - Stan Freberg |
| Cinderella - Jack Ross |
| Rindercella - Archie Campbell |
| Little Red Riding Hood - Al "Jazzbo" Collins |
| Jack and The Beanstalk - Al "Jazzbo" Collins |
| 3 Hep Piggies, The - 5 3/4 Year Old Humorous Dian |
| Three Little Pigs - Green Jelly |
| Goldilocks and The Three Bears (A _Bebop's Fable_) - Steve Allen |
| Bedtime Story - Vaughn Meader & Norma McMillan |
| Three Little Bops - Stan Freberg |
| Jack the Giant Killer - Andy Griffith |
| Hour 3 |
| Fairy Tales & Nursery Rhymes - Meyer & Drake |
| N.R.L. (Nursery Rhyme Lawyer Song) - Throwing Toasters |
| Mother Goose - Paul Aldrich |
| Mother Goose Rap - Nomel Emil |
| Mudder Goose - Joe Subway |
| Rock Around Mother Goose - Barry Gordon with The Ray Charles Singers |
| Fairytale - Alexander Rybak |
| Humpty Dumpty, The - Bobby Pickett |
| Cinderella vs Belle: Princess Rap Battle - Whitney Avalon feat. Sarah Michelle Gellar |
| Wacked-Out Five |
| Complete Ill-Advised Interview, The - Mike Minnick |
| Run Barry Run - great Luke Ski, The |
| Hamilton Polka, The - "Weird Al" Yankovic |
| Alfred Matthew Yankovic - Michael William Hunter |
| Wrestlemania - WWF Superstars |
| Bonus Round |
| Dirty Nursery Rhymes - 2 Live Crew |
| Adam Sandler Song, The - Nostalgia Critic, The |